If a Horse Had Words

Starred review from April 16, 2018
In her first book for children, Canadian author Cooper offers a tale of a foal and her boy that blends the scope of a novel with the grace of a poem. Born on a spring morning, the foal tries out her long legs and sinks into a badger hole, from which she’s hauled out by a man and his freckled, cowboy-hatted companion: “If a horse had words,” Cooper writes, in a phrase that serves as the story’s title and leitmotif, “the word would be... boy.” Boy and foal watch the seasons change contentedly together until one day, the boy tries to ride her, and she tosses him. She has to go, the man says, and, in a wrenching moment, she’s auctioned off. But she meets the boy again in a triumphant moment that redeems their separation. Cooper’s lilting voice dances through the story, while folk-naive watercolors by Eldridge, in her picture-book debut, capture the foal’s lovely lines. Readers drawn to stories about the unbreakable bonds between children and animals will remember this one. Ages 4–8.

May 1, 2018

K-Gr 3-When the foal is born she takes in her surroundings. As she stands for the first time, her back legs are stuck in a muddy hole, but a young boy and his dad come to help her free; still, she's forever fearful of the ground. As she grows into a horse, she has many experiences with the boy, running and jumping, and watching the seasons pass. Eventually, readers learn her name, Red Badger, and in her dislike of the ground, she accidentally bucks the boy off her back. His dad decides to sell Red Badger and she ends up at the rodeo. The boy, now older, arrives to ride at the rodeo. They recognize each other and their reunion brings them both incredible joy. This book is written in a poetic and lyrical manner, from the perspective of the horse. The watercolor illustrations give the book a dreamy quality, which fits perfectly with the text. VERDICT A solid and engaging choice for horse lovers or anyone who has ever bonded with an animal.-Shana Shea, Windsor Public Library, CT

Copyright 2018 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

April 15, 2018
The friendship between a boy and a horse is explored in this picture book.A newborn foal, struggling to rise, slips and becomes trapped in a badger hole. This tension-filled narrative beginning is agreeably softened by Eldridge's airy, whimsical watercolor illustrations that give the moment a calm, problem-to-be-resolved feel. Sure enough, a man and a boy arrive and pull the unhurt foal to freedom, and the basic premise of the story is neatly set: The foal, named Red Badger, and the boy become friends, and they both dislike the ground. When Red Badger is grown, the boy tries to ride him but is bucked off. The boy laughs, but the man decides to sell Red Badger at auction. They are reunited much later at the rodeo where Red Badger is a bucking bronco and the boy has become a bronco rider. Cooper's narrative is soundly constructed, full of poetic circularity, and the illustrations make an airy counterpoint, with plenty of white space to reinforce the idea of movement and open country. But the underlying presumption of the dominion of human over beast is an atypical theme for a children's picture book, and readers may find the idea of Red Badger's ending up as a bucking bronco in a rodeo less than nourishing.A skillfully told, whimsically illustrated story of friendship, with a rodeo aspect that may limit its audience. (Picture book. 5-8)

COPYRIGHT(2018) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

July 1, 2018
When colt Red Badger is born, a boy helps her stand for the first time. Simple, sensory text incorporates small details to give a horse's-eye view as Red Badger grows and is sold to a rodeo. Naturalistic, angular watercolors with plenty of white space add buoyancy, although the ending (boy and horse are momentarily reunited at a bucking bronco event) is rather abrupt and unsatisfying.

(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)