Perfect Family

April 24, 2000
Set in 1950s small-town North Carolina and narrated by a "good" girl who gets pregnant, this novel would seem to be familiar--except that Oughton's (Music from a Place Called Half Moon) lyrical prose and perceptive characterizations revitalize the plot. The narrator is 15-year-old Welcome (she was named by her older sister, Evelyn Sue, who "wanted me to always know that, even though I was number three, I was certainly welcome"). Bright and unusually ambitious (she wants to be a pediatrician), she struggles with adolescent awkwardness, strict parents and her first heartbreak. On the rebound, she lets a boy she doesn't love have intercourse with her--just once--and she gets pregnant. Her family ships her off to her childless aunt and uncle, which gives Welcome a chance to ponder her future. The characters throughout are memorable; like Welcome, each uniquely combines ordinary vulnerability with unexpected stores of strength. For example, Evelyn Sue runs off to Hollywood in search of her beloved James Dean, but she returns with real wisdom and adult resolve. Mrs. Horn, neighbor to Welcome's aunt and uncle, survived WWII in a prisoner-of-war camp, feeding her infant twins on raw bird's eggs. The pacing is not always consistent; it's Welcome herself, not any inherent dramatic tension, that will hold readers. Ages 10-14.

April 1, 2000
Gr 8-10-Welcome Marie O'Neal, 15, is the baby of her family, growing up in a sleepy North Carolina town in the 1950s. Her mother makes decisions based on what the neighbors will say; Welcome and her older sister can never live up to their father's expectations. Evelyn Sue dreams of a different world and is "in love" with James Dean, and the girls' older brother is busy with a family of his own. The protagonist gives her heart to the young man of her dreams, and, when she is rejected, seeks solace in her newly found sexuality with a friend. When Welcome tells her parents that she is pregnant, they send her away in shame to live with a childless aunt and uncle in Virginia. After a difficult birth and the realization that she cannot properly care for Adam with a part-time job and high school to finish, the teen decides to give him up to her aunt's more capable care and return to school. The last page presents an invitation, from Welcome to Adam and his family, to her graduation from medical school. The idea that if you have a baby at a young age outside of marriage, a willing relative may step in so that you can still follow your dreams is not a particularly constructive fairy tale. A marginal addition for large general collections, where it will be surrounded by some more realistic literature.-Kim Harris, Newman Riga Library, Churchville, NY

Copyright 2000 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

April 15, 2000
Gr. 6^-9. The oddly named Welcome Marie O'Neal is the product of a 1950s eastern North Carolina small town, a gossip-hungry place where a teenager who becomes pregnant is sent away "to boarding school" or "to visit family." Oughton takes readers back to a time before legalized abortion, when young women visited grimy, back-street houses and often fled in fear, choosing to raise their babies when faced with the reality of their choices. This is Welcome's story, but it is also the story of a family that supports and loves--and forgives--its own, a family that works. It's about a young woman growing up who makes the ultimate sacrifice and atones for it. And though the story takes place years ago, it's still relevant to teens today: it deals with making choices, looking to the future, and realizing that, though no family is truly perfect, some families are just right for new babies and teens. ((Reviewed April 15, 2000))(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2000, American Library Association.)

July 1, 2000
Welcome ONeal feels she has destroyed her perfect family when heartbreak over one boy leads to an accidental pregnancy by another. Living with relatives as the months pass, Welcome wonders if she has the maturity and ability to raise her baby herself. Set in the 1950s South, this well-characterized interior novel explores choices and consequences surrounding teen pregnancy.

(Copyright 2000 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)