July 15, 2016
A little, blonde, white girl named Charlotte has only hand-me-down dresses from her older sisters until they work together to create an unusual, new dress for her as a surprise.Charlotte is the youngest of six daughters in the Bartlett-Kruger family, which lives in an elegant mansion with a white butler, uniformed, white maids, and a pet peacock. Despite the family's obvious wealth, little Charlotte seems to be the Cinderella of the family as far as her clothing and possessions are concerned. She mends her sisters' castoff dolls and stuffed animals and wears only one old dress with a patch and boots that need resoling. When the parents decide to have a fancy party, Charlotte is sad because her only choices of dresses are tired and worn outfits offered by her older sisters. After Charlotte cries herself to sleep, her sisters work with the stuffed animals and dolls to combine bits of the dresses with household items. Together they create a lovely ball gown fit for a princess, "made not only of hand-me-down garments, but with sisterly love." Intricately detailed illustrations impart a fairy-tale flavor to the story, incorporating sumptuous details of the family mansion and the sisters' many costumes. Though the sisters are totally wrapped up in their wardrobe choices and several elements of the plot require the willing suspension of disbelief, young readers who like fashion design and fairy tales will enjoy Charlotte's transformation into the budding belle of the ball. A modern take on the Cinderella story, with kind and loving sisters replacing the mean stepsisters. (Picture book. 3-6)
COPYRIGHT(2016) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
October 1, 2016
K-Gr 2-Charlotte is the youngest of six girls in the lavish Bartlett-Kruger household. While she enjoys playing with her sisters and welcomes their outgrown toys, Charlotte dislikes being stuck with their hand-me-down clothes. When their parents plan a fancy dress-up party, the girls anticipate wearing a stylish new outfit, all except Charlotte, who expects to be the wallflower of the group. Extending some kindhearted effort, the sisters embellish their old dresses with handy items around the house to create a dress "made not only of hand-me-down garments, but with sisterly love." Krauss's intricate, meticulous pastel illustrations are a feast for the eyes for fashion buffs, though the outfits (reminiscent of 1920s or 1930s splendor) may not resonate with 21st-century children. Fans of "Cinderella" should be satisfied when Charlotte emerges for her grand entrance wearing a ball gown fit for a princess. The dress is featured on the book's front cover, which may be a bit of a spoiler, but those who savor a typical happy ending will not be disappointed. Children with older sisters may relish a story featuring the youngest shining as the center of attention, and it is somewhat satisfying being presented with a twist on the evil stepsisters of Cinderella. VERDICT A stylish picture book for young would-be fashionistas and those who love dressing up, but the narrative pales in comparison with the images.-Etta Anton, Yeshiva of Central Queens, NY
Copyright 2016 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
July 1, 2017
When their parents announce a fancy party, the five older Bartlett-Kruger sisters disappoint Charlotte, the youngest, with their hand-me-down options. In the end, they surprise her with a kindhearted solution. The stylishly detailed illustrations pay special attention to furniture patterns and decor, though the text isn't as memorable. Nevertheless, the story will delight dress-up enthusiasts and budding upcyclers.
(Copyright 2017 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)